i'd probably say 4.5/10. I really like the idea of the rubber players that cannot be broken, but the hair styles on some of them are just awful! I really don't like the bases; the touch is just too heavy for me and I find it difficult to control/chip with them. The other bits from the box set are ok, goals are sturdy enough and the pitch is alright, an improvement compared to the Dream team stadium pitch but doesn't play as well as a baize or an astro. The idea of generic teams is a good one and I like the numbers on the back of the shirts, but I just don't see kids taking to it as much when the kits change every season. Poor marketing has pretty much let it down so far; if sales flop at xmas then it'll be the end of it in the shops